Progressive underpayment in Ohio.
Three layers stack here: Progressive's documented claims-handling patterns, Ohio's statutes for unfair claims practices and appraisal, and the most recent court opinions that have shaped how those collide. We pull the case law live from CourtListener and the complaint index live from NAIC — both update without manual edits.
The Ohio statute
What your carrier owes you under state law
Ohio Revised Code § 3901.21 (Unfair Claims Practices). Common-law bad-faith claim recognized under Hoskins v. Aetna Life Insurance.
How long you have to act
15 years for written-contract breach (one of the longest in the country); bad-faith torts: 4 years from accrual.
Your fastest enforcement lever
Ohio courts uphold appraisal clauses. Recent rulings tighten what 'amount of loss' includes — generally not coverage disputes.
🔴 Live intel on Progressive
Recent court opinions mentioning Progressive
- Progressive Direct Insurance Company, Petitioner: v. Andrew OrtizSupreme Court of Colorado · 2026-06-01
- Davenport v. Progressive Direct Ins.Ohio Court of Appeals · 2025-07-10
- Alexis Jones v. Progressive Northern Insurance CompanySupreme Court of South Carolina · 2026-04-22
- Heather Schroeder v. Progressive Paloverde Insurance CompanyCourt of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · 2025-07-25
Progressive lowballed you in Ohio?
Your free Recovery Playbook will cross-reference Progressive's estimate against Ohio statutes, the IICRC standard for your damage type, and the case law above. 48 hours. No commitment.
Get My Recovery Playbook →